+1 (262) 255 0223

prOtotype pitfalls

How to avoid common mistakes when moving from prototype to production tooling

Issue 081

⚠️ The Problem: Why Relying Only on EDM or CNC Prototypes Can Lead Your Tooling Astray

If you’re managing tooling or new product introductions, you know CNC or EDM prototypes are go-to tools for early fit and form checks. They’re fast and precise, giving you a tangible feel for your design. But here’s the catch: these prototypes don’t mimic the complex metal deformation of progressive die stamping.

Prototypes—often cut or machined from solid blocks—lack the metal flow, springback, and strain hardening that stamping introduces. Even emerging sheet metal rapid prototyping techniques haven’t yet fully replicated these realities.

So, when tooling design blindly copies prototype geometry, it risks costly misalignments, scrap, and production delays.

🦸 You’re the Hero: Navigating the Gap Between Prototype and Production

You’re juggling deadlines, specs, and cross-team expectations, trying to deliver stamped parts that hit quality and schedule.

Your challenge: to use prototypes wisely—not as absolute blueprints—but as references that tooling experts can translate into real-world stamped geometry.

👷‍♂️ Your Guide: How Modern Die Design Goes Beyond Machined Prototypes

Here’s what’s really happening:

  1. CNC and EDM parts are machined, not formed—so no springback or metal flow shows up.

  2. Stamping reshapes metal through bending, stretching, and compressing, creating stresses prototypes can’t replicate.

  3. Modern die design anticipates this, using techniques like incremental forming, stress-relief cuts, and servo-driven presses that adapt in real time.

  4. Digital twins and advanced stamping simulations now help engineers predict deformation—bridging prototype and production realities.

  5. Over-correcting based on prototype shape—like adding unnecessary bend allowances or changing flange sizes—can ruin tool performance.

  6. Material variability from batch to batch also affects how parts form, making rigid prototype-based designs risky without real-world validation.

🛠️ A Clear Plan: Bridging Prototypes and Tooling for Production Success

  1. Use prototypes for early concept and fit checks—not final tooling geometry.

  2. Involve tooling experts early to interpret prototypes with stamping realities in mind.

  3. Apply stamping-specific DfM checks—minimum bend radii, flange widths, and progressive forming stages.

  4. Use digital simulation and physical inspection data (including AI-enhanced metrology) to create rapid feedback loops.

  5. Recognize and plan for material variability in design and prototyping phases.

  6. Keep communication flowing between engineering, sourcing, and production teams to catch issues early.

🌟 The Reward: Dies That Deliver in Real Life, On Time and On Budget

Tooling designed with real stamping forces and material behavior in mind yields first-run parts that meet specs—cutting scrap by significant margins and speeding time to market.

Your team avoids costly redesigns and last-minute firefights, earning trust and respect across departments.

Ready to Get Your Dies Right From the Start?

Don’t let CNC or EDM prototypes lead your tooling down the wrong path. Combine early prototyping with stamping expertise and digital workflows—and build dies that perform where it counts: in production.

Gromax Precision Die & Mfg., Inc. specializes in designing and manufacturing precision metal stamped parts and tooling, including progressive stamping dies and custom equipment. With an on-time delivery rate of 99.68% and a defect rate of just 0.066%, the company ensures exceptional reliability and quality. 

Gromax is ISO 9001:2015 certified and ITAR registered, serving industries such as medical, defense, aerospace, industrial automation, and automotive with high-quality, innovative solutions.

Copyright © 2024 Gromax Precision Die & Mfg. Inc. ​

info@gromaxprecision.com

W185 N11474 Whitney Drive Germantown, WI 5302